|
|
Day 3 or Day 5? Advantages and Disadvantages
Lyubov Mykhaylyshyn
IVF center Intersono, Lviv, Ukraine
OBJECTIVE: During the last decade, the extension of embryo culture to day 5 has gained popularity in IVF practice (Wilson et al., 2002). There are few scientific reasons to compare cleavage-stage and blastocyst-stage embryo transfers. The first: an embryo does not implant before day 5, better synchronization with an endometrium already affected by an IVF stimulated cycle, blastocysts have better correlation between morphology and euploidy status . On the other hand, blastocysts have certain drawbacks, such as the lack of one day co-culture with endometrial cells (an embryo descends into the uterine cavity on day 4); the increased possibility for some embryos not to develope into blastocysts in vitro. It has been reported that Y-bearing preembryos (males) develop at faster rates than X-bearing ones (females). If this theory is proved accurate, one may expect a skew in sex ratios after day 5 transfer, as the most advanced blastocysts are almost always replaced preferentially.
The aim of this study is to compare clinical pregnancy rate, implantation rate, multiply gestation rate and male/female sex ratio after blastocyst and cleavage-stage transfers.
DESIGN: Retrospective (randomized) analysis
MATERIALS and METHODS: Analysis and comparison of 336 fresh and cryocycles with day 5 embryo transfer (ET) and 296 fresh and cryocycles with day 3 ET performed in Medical Center Intersono between April, 17 2007 and June, 24 2008.
RESULTS: Biochemical pregnancy rate was 36,5% on day 3 ET and 39% for ET on 5 day. Clinical pregnancy rate for day 3 ET was 28,4% compared to 36,3% for ET of day 5 . Implantation rate was higher on day 5 than on day 3 (19, 24% vs 14,18%). Transfer of 5 day blastocyst on fresh and cryocycles showed the same biochemical and clinical pregnancy rate (43%) and implantation rate 23,4% compared to 16,1% for morula transfer on day 5 and 0% for compacting embryos and cleavage-stage embryos on day 5. Multiply gestation rate on day 5 was less than on day 3 (36, 07% vs 38,11%) with mean 2,7 embryos transfered on day 5 and 3,1 on day 3. The male-to-female ratio (1,35) was found to be higher for offspring resulting from a day 5 ET compared to 1,05 in natural cycles.
CONCLUSIONS: Both cleavage-stage and blastocyst-stage embryo transfer policies have advantages and drawbacks. Our data presented in this study has shown better outcomes using 5 day ET. Not always extended culture will turn enough retrieved eggs into a blastocyst. Our data support the observation of an altered sex ratio imbalance favoring male offspring with blastocyst transfer. However further studies and researches are needed in group of day 3 ET.
|

Skype: Intersono.1
ICQ: 57 65 46 884
E-mail: reception@intersono.ua
Розвиток клініки
 |